The casualties at first seemed fairly innocent; several cheap plastic hangers (all blue, oddly enough) and Wallace's head from a Wallace and Gromit fridge magnet. On a sadder note I broke a gorgeous glass mug we got at the Smithsonian show last year, though we're going to take the opportunity in replacing it to get another pair.
The worst of the loss was uncovered when we began working on the books, most of which had been shoved, unopened, into the outdoor closet of the apartment. We had planned from the beginning to have a house within a year and figured unpacking would be almost redundant. Not to mention there would have been no room to put them.
Unfortunately there was a leak in the closet. Many of the books damaged will be easy to replace; nearly all of my Far Side books, but they're still in print and can be found in good used condition easily; quite a few of our Calvin and Hobbes, two of our User Friendly books, and one Fox Trot compilation. Our copy of The Silmarillion was nailed, but it was a mass market paperback. In sadder news, several out of print books in my fairy-tale, folk-tale, and Brother's Grimm collection are complete losses, as is my Dictionary of Fairies, which I discovered is also out of print. The gorgeous illustrated Tolkien volume we got at Elliot Bay in Seattle and the copy of Gaiman's Angels and Visitations, which I spent quite a while tracking down and completely surprised Andy with, are also damaged.
All of these books can be replaced, some at greater cost than others. We were going to put in a claim with our renter's insurance, but upon looking up the policy we discovered that we have a $1000.00 deductible. I went and found equal replacements (eg first editions for first editions, new mass market paperbacks for the comic books, and so on), and discovered that after the deductible we would have been eligible for $32. and change, and that's only if the adjusters didn't do something nasty like "Sorry, we'll only pay for the minimum replacements, so give us a list of paperback costs".
Many of the books are still readable, and none need to be replaced immediately. Still, those of you who have renter's insurance, please check the deductibles and also make sure you're covered for standing water and/or floods. Had the books been damaged by the runoff from our undrained porch (rather than the gaping leak which opened up in the ceiling) we would not have been able to make a claim at all. I'll be nudging "Get flood insurance" to my priority list for the coming week.